Saving and budgeting

Should You Save or Pay Off Debt First?

Whether to build savings or pay off debt first, how to do both on a tight budget, and how to keep a savings habit going while you repay.

pay off debt

Key takeaways

  • It’s rarely either-or. Most people do best with a small emergency fund first, then extra payments on their most expensive debt.
  • Always pay at least the minimum on every account, so you don’t fall into arrears.
  • High-interest debt, like credit cards, store cards and short-term loans, usually costs more than savings can earn, so pay it down faster.
  • Without any savings, an unexpected expense can push you straight back into debt.
  • Small, automatic savings add up. Start with an amount you won’t miss.

When money is tight, it can feel like you have to choose: put extra money towards your debt, or start saving. Both matter, and the right balance depends on your situation.

This guide explains a simple order of priorities, when saving should come first, and how to build a savings habit even while you’re paying off debt.

The short answer: a simple order of priorities

  1. Pay the minimum on every account. Missing payments leads to arrears, fees and a lower credit score, so this always comes first.
  2. Build a small emergency fund. Aim for R5,000 to R10,000, or about one month of essential expenses, to start with. This stops a burst geyser or a car repair from going onto a credit card.
  3. Pay extra on your most expensive debt. Put any money left over towards the debt with the highest interest rate, usually credit cards, store cards or short-term loans.
  4. Grow your emergency fund. Once high-interest debt is under control, build your savings towards three to six months of essential expenses.
  5. Save for longer-term goals. Then move on to goals like a deposit, education or retirement.

Why an emergency fund comes before extra debt payments

If every spare rand goes to debt and something unexpected happens, there’s nowhere to turn except more credit. That undoes your progress and can start a cycle that’s hard to break.

A small cushion means a surprise expense stays a surprise expense, not a new debt. It doesn’t need to be big to make a difference.

Why high-interest debt comes next

The interest on credit cards, store cards and short-term loans is usually much higher than anything a savings account pays. So every extra rand you put towards that debt saves you more than the same rand would earn in savings. For example, if your credit card charges 22% interest a year and your savings account pays 5%, you lose more on the debt than you gain on the savings.

Two common ways to tackle several debts:

AvalancheSnowball
What you pay off firstThe debt with the highest interest rateThe debt with the smallest balance
Why it worksYou pay less interest overallQuick wins keep you motivated
Best forPeople motivated by saving moneyPeople who need to see progress

With either method, you keep paying the minimum on everything else. When one debt is paid off, you add what you were paying on it to the next one.

Doing both: an example plan

You don’t have to choose one or the other. Once you have a small emergency fund, a split like this keeps both moving:

  • Save R300 a month to keep growing your emergency fund.
  • Pay R800 a month extra towards your credit card or other most expensive debt.
  • Pay the minimum on lower-interest debt, like a student loan or home loan.

Review the plan every month and adjust it as your income and expenses change. Money is emotional too, so if having no savings worries you more than your debt balance, it’s fine to put a little more into savings. What matters is making steady progress on both.

When saving should come first

Some situations call for putting more into savings before paying debt off faster:

  • You have no savings at all. Even a small buffer protects you from new debt.
  • Your income is irregular. If you’re self-employed, work on commission or have seasonal income, a bigger cushion helps you keep up repayments in lean months.
  • Your job feels uncertain. Savings give you time if your income stops.
  • Your debt is low-interest. Some debts, like a home loan, cost less in interest than high-interest debt. Paying the minimum while you build savings can make sense.

How to build a savings habit while paying off debt

  1. Start with a reason. You’re more likely to keep going when you know why you’re saving, whether it’s school uniforms in January or peace of mind.
  2. Start small. R100 or R200 a month is a real start. The habit matters more than the amount at first.
  3. Pay yourself first. Set up a debit order into savings on payday, before you start spending.
  4. Keep savings separate. A separate account you don’t carry a card for makes it less tempting to dip in.
  5. Give every rand a job. If your budget is tight, try the 80/10/10 approach: 80% for living expenses and debt repayments, 10% for savings and 10% for flexible spending. The 50/30/20 rule is another simple option. Adjust the split to suit you.
  6. Use windfalls wisely. Split a bonus, tax refund or gift between savings and your most expensive debt.
  7. Increase it as debts clear. When you pay off an account, move part of that instalment into savings.
  8. Be kind to yourself. Some months you’ll save less, and that’s fine. If an emergency or a bad month throws you off, start again. Progress beats perfection.

What this means for your credit score

Paying every account on time is the most important thing for your credit score. Bringing down balances on credit cards and store cards helps too, because it lowers how much of your available credit you’re using.

An emergency fund protects your score indirectly. It means you’re less likely to miss a payment or max out a card when something goes wrong. Read How to Improve Your Credit Score for more.

Before you decide which account to pay off first, you can use Score Lab to see whether paying off one account before another could move your score up, down or keep it the same.

Frequently asked questions

How much should I have in my emergency fund?

Start with R5,000 to R10,000, or about one month of essential expenses. Over time, aim for three to six months. If your income is irregular, a bigger cushion helps.

Should I use my savings to pay off debt?

It can make sense for expensive debt, but don’t empty your emergency fund. Keep enough to cover a surprise expense, so you don’t end up borrowing again.

Is it worth saving if I’m earning less interest than I’m paying on debt?

For a small emergency fund, yes, because it protects you from new debt. Beyond that, extra money usually works harder paying down high-interest debt.

Which debt should I pay off first?

Pay the minimum on everything, then put extra towards either the highest-interest debt (the avalanche method) or the smallest balance (the snowball method).

What if I can’t afford to save anything?

Start by tracking your spending for a month to see where your money goes. If your debt repayments leave nothing over, talk to your credit providers or read our guide to debt review in South Africa.

Test it before you decide

Score Lab shows whether a financial action could move your score up, down or keep it the same.

Try Score Lab for free
About the Splendi Cred-Ed team

Cred-Ed articles are written by Splendi’s content team, using insights from the credit specialists behind Splendi. They’re reviewed for accuracy before publishing and updated when things change.

This article is for information only and isn’t financial advice. Splendi doesn’t provide personalised financial, investment, legal or tax advice. For advice about your own situation, speak to a qualified financial adviser.